Fire Workgroup
- 1. Members
- 2. Coordination Committee Meetings
- 2.1 June 6, 2019
2.12.2 May 2, 20192.22.3 April 4, 20192.32.4 March 7, 20192.42.5 February 7, 20192.5 December2.6 December 6, 20182.6 November2.7 November 1, 20182.7 October2.8 October 4, 20182.8 September2.9 September 6, 20182.9 August2.10 August 2, 20182.10 July2.11 July 12, 20182.11 June2.12 June 7, 20182.12 May2.13 May 9, 20182.13 April2.14 April 5, 20182.14 March2.15 March 1, 2018
Inventory Collaborative Google Drive Link
Members
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader- See following link for list of members:
Coordination Committee Meetings
June 6, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Agenda
- Roll call
- Action Items from last call
- 2016 Inventory to be presented at EPA Emissions Inventory Conference Jul 29-Aug 2
- Schedule
- Post preliminary 2016v1 emissions next week!
- Short call in late June: Last minute feedback for 2016v1
- July 18 Workgroup call: Recap of 2016v1
- Last workgroup call to be August call
May 2, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader
Agenda
- Roll call
- Action Items from last call
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in upcoming meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- EPA and NCDENR met; may have something to present during June call
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Discuss if this is still doable for June?
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
- Possibly in 2020 TBD
- CARB and EPA to discuss recent modeling findings Re: Soberanes fire (CARB and EPA)
- Met this week
- Soberanes Fire, CA (pdf)
- CARB has provided event data from FOFEM database (5/1/2019)
- Next steps to get any improvements TBD
- Provide workgroup with findings of top fire cases where acres_bruned-PM2.5-SO2 emissions high for a daily location (Vukovich)
- Spreadsheet part of meeting invite (also available here Top daily emissions cases in 2016beta (xls) )
- Status of 2016v1 fire processing update (Vukovich)
- New USFS, USFWS, and NJ data formatted and ready for use
- Changes to NASF database complete
- Next call is Thursday June 6th at 1PM ET
- Expecting preliminary 2016v1 results before and during June call
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- EPA met with NCDENR and will continue to discuss possible topics to present to Workgroup
- EPA to follow up with Tom Moore about future-year alternative scenarios for fires to see if there will be a presentation for June call
- EPA met with CARB about Soberanes fire and July 26th high emissions issue
- CARB provided event information for Soberanes fires; EPA will examine
- T. Wickman suggested looking at duff consumption
- G. Pouliot suggested changing temporal profile for July 26th
- Ferron suggested looking at canopy consumption percentage for fuel *(default may be set to 60%)
- EPA went over top daily PM2.5 emitting cases with Workgroup
- One result is some bogus fire information will be removed from National Association of State Foresters (NASF) data that is input into SmartFire2
- Preliminary SmartFire2 run for 2016v1 is about to start at EPA
- Results will be shared with Workgroup
Action Items
- Provide data summaries of preliminary version 1 Smartfire2/Bluesky simulation to workgroup (EPA)
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in June's meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
April 4, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader
Agenda
- Roll call
- EPA Emissions Inventory Conference in Dallas on July 29 - August 2, 2019
- Action Items from last call
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (ALL)
- http://views.cira.colostate.edu/wiki/wiki/10197#Documentation
- Workgroup members encouraged to provide feedback
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Received; hope to implement in 2016v1
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios (Mavko, Moore)
- Future Fire Scenarios for Regional Haze Planning (pdf)
- Discussion
- Update on 2016v1 plan (Vukovich)
- Workgroup Plans (pdf)
- Next call is on Thursday May 2nd at 1pm ET, 11am MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- Workgroup members encouraged to read fire documentation and provide feedback
- NJ fire information to be used in v1
- Matt Mavko presented issues involved when coming up with future year fire scenarios
- Discussion afterwards included topics
- What area will be covered? USA only
- Boundary conditions for year 2028
- How many scenarios? 2 to be used may examine more
- WRAP driving this work but could use input from Plains and SE USA
- Matt can provide more details of this work during June's workgroup call
- SE US : Randy Strait gave a quick update on Regional Haze modeling in SE and prescribed fire impacts
- Vukovich gave a quick update on 2016v1 plans in the coming months
- Mentioned an air quality modeling effort that found a possible issue with Soberanes fire in CA on July 26, 2016
- Tom Moore suggested looking at other possible similar cases
- EPA has started this process already
- Tom Moore suggested a webinar or meeting of land managers and states to discuss 2016 modeling platform issues related to fire information issues encountered.
Action Items
- Provide workgroup with findings of top 25 fire cases where acres_bruned-PM2.5-SO2 emissions high for a daily location (Vukovich)
- CARB and EPA to discuss recent modeling findings Re: Soberanes fire (CARB and EPA)
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in May's meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
March 7, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- EPA Emissions Inventory Conference in Dallas on July 29 - August 2, 2019
- Training thoughts survey (optional): https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/9NR3FGG
- Biomass burning/Fires session very likely; need co-chair person for session
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Provided 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Update on timing for New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Pre-version 1 Smartfire-Bluesky run planned for late March-early April
- Need time to review all of the impacts of the new input data
- Workgroup Plans (pdf)
- Summary of other N. American fires used in regional modeling domains (Canada/Mexico) for 2016 (Vukovich)
- ptfire_othna sector (pdf)
- Next call is April 4, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
- Agenda for this call will include alternative future-year fire scenarios ppt and discussion
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- Fire/Biomass Burning session at EPA's EIC needs a co-chair
- Fill out optional survey on EPA EIC desired training
- New Jersey fire activity for 2016 coming real soon
- Pre-v1 Smartfire-Bluesky planned to start late March or early April
- A summary of 2016 fire season for Canada and Mexico was presented
- GA DNR suggested examining other global inventories (e.g. GFED)
Action Items
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
February 7, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- January's call was cancelled due to government shutdown
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- 2016 beta fires inventory and report/summaries located on Google Drive
- https://drive.google.com/drive/u/1/folders/15HbKPUiV-YOLhXYCu3nNyjyB4rjTEnG5
- Includes ancillary data (profiles, xrefs) needed for emissions modeling
- More 2016 beta fires reports
- Update on beta documentation
- Moving towards 2016 version 1 (pdf)
- Does any federal/states/local/tribal agency plan on submitting new fire activity data for 2016 version 1?
- Does any federal/states/local/tribal agency plan on quality assuring the beta inventory and providing feedback?
- Next call March 7, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- 2016 beta inventory data and summaries/reports now available
- 2016 beta documentation will be made available to the workgroup around Feb 15th timeframe
- FACTS fire information database contains prescribed burns only according to USFS
- FACTS will be in used in 2016v1 development
- Randy Strait mentioned that some latitude-longitude coordinates only have two decimal places and may not be accurate enough for use
- NFPORS fire information will also be used in 2016v1 development and it also contains USFWS fire information
- New Jersey has indicated it will submit some 2016 fire activity data for use in 2016v1
Action Items
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Provide a summary of international fires used in regional modeling domains (Canada/Mexico) for 2016 (Vukovich)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
December 6, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Follow-up on NCDENR on plan for 2016v1 (EPA)
- Final 2016 beta emissions inventory (Vukovich)
- Last minute change to 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- Inventory files located at: https://drive.google.com/open?id=15HbKPUiV-YOLhXYCu3nNyjyB4rjTEnG5
- Provide beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
- Next call January 10, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- T. Moore may be able to update at next call on Rx fire problem statement doc
- J Vukovich went over the 2016beta last minute change involved the national fire info dataset called MTBS.
- Please see pdf listed in agenda
- Future work with more national fire info datasets mentioned
- P Corrigan (UT/Forest Service) mentioned he has input on these national datasets
- 2016 beta fire inventories released and available (see link in Agenda)
- 2016beta documentation: hope to make progress before next call
- No future-year fire scenarios discussed
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- P. Corrigan to provide input on national fire info datasets
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
November 1, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Communicated with AIRFIRE team that we have 2016 beta data they can test with latest BlueSky software
- Follow-up with M. Mavko on what could be done to use NFEI tool with 2016 data (Vukovich, Moore, Mavko)
- Provided data to Matt that may allow him to use NFEI tool for 2016
- Follow-up on NCDENR submitted vs. draft 2016 beta acres burned differences (EPA)
- Provided reports to NCDENR at: ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/beta/reports/fires/NCDENR/
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Actual inventory files to be made available very soon!
- Final summary of 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Next Call December 6th at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- USFS AIRFIRE communication continuing
- Matt Mavko has the necessary 2016 beta data to try to use the NFEI tool
- EPA will followup with NCDENR after call about path for 2016v1
- Summary of 2016 beta inventory discussed and reports provided
- Urban fuel category discussion
- Possible improvements for 2016v1 discussion
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Follow-up on NCDENR on plan for 2016v1 (EPA)
- Finalize 2016 beta emissions inventory (ALL)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
October 4, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup
- Summary of 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- State reports (2016 alpha vs 2016 beta version)
- ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/beta/reports/fires/2016alpha_beta_postBSF_comparison.xlsx : Wildfire and prescribed fires state comparison (updated Oct 31, 2018 !!) (xls)
- Agricultural burns state comparison (xls)
- Draft outline for technical documentation (pdf)
- Documentation can be delivered after the beta inventory is released
- Introduction to a Fire Evaluation tool (Mavko)
- http://nfei2014.airsci.com/2014_fire_nei_eval
- being used for 2014 but possible use for 2016
- Next Meeting November 1 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- Summary of draft 2016 beta inventory discussed and initial reports provided
- Trent Wickman requested a report in a format he provided previously for 2016 alpha
- Randy Strait mentioned that state-submitted data for beta version didn't match up as far as acres burned
- Draft outline of 2016 beta documentation discussed
- Matt Mavko shared the Fire Evaluation tool (NFEI tool)
- http://nfei2014.airsci.com/2014_fire_nei_eval
- discussed needs for use with 2016 inventory
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Follow-up on NCDENR submitted vs. draft 2016 beta acres burned differences (EPA)
- Finalize 2016 beta emissions inventory (ALL)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Follow-up with M. Mavko on what could be done to use NFEI tool with 2016 data (Vukovich, Moore, Mavko)
September 6, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Plan for 2016 beta version fires(pdf)(dated Sep 6, 2018)
- Summarize data received from states, tribes and other government agencies
- Other fire information to be used
- Fuel-bed information updated
- Technical documentation for beta version discussion (Tom Moore)
- Beta Schedule
- Week of Sept 24th: Draft beta version available for QA
- Oct 04: Another workgroup call; early draft beta QA findings; tech doc progress update
- October: More QA and work on tech doc for beta version
- Nov 01: Another workgroup call and release beta version and tech doc
- Next Meeting Oct 4 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Prescribed Burn Problem statement discussion
- More states want to contribute
- Discussion on need for Ag burning documentation
- Pouliot has published paper
- Will include for beta documentation
- Summary of changes to inventory input for 2016 beta presented
- More information on NASF and Landfire v1.4 desired
- HAPS discussion: why is this needed?
- Ag burn plan for 2017NEI discussion
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide draft beta emissions to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Prepare outline for technical documentation (Moore)
August 2, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
- NEI: emissions factor and speciation update (EPA-ORD, Amara Holder)
- US Forest Service QA (Trent Wickman)
- Technical documentation for beta version discussion (Tom Moore)
- List of potenial improvements for beta version (pdf)(dated Aug 2, 2018)
- Upcoming schedule
- Aug 17: Inventory/activity changes due
- Sep 06: Next workgroup conference call scheduled for Thursday September 6, 2018 at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
- Sep 21: Draft beta version available for QA
- Oct 04: Another workgroup call; early draft beta QA findings; tech doc progress update
- October: More QA and finalize tech doc for beta version
- Nov 01: Another workgroup call and release beta version
Minutes/Notes
- Activity/emissions updates for beta version due Aug 17th
- EPA meeting with USFS AIRFIRE via conference call very soon
- Amara Holder presented updates on PM emissions factors and speciation from EPA-ORD research efforts
- PM2.5 emissions would increase based on these initial lab results
- MN peat moss/other fuels lab burns delayed; may begin in September
- Black Carbon impacts discussed by group
- Trent Wickman, USFS, presented his QA of MN fires
- See spreadsheet
- 7 prescribed fires should be ag fires
- Acreage differences hint at other federal databases missing
- EPA: only databases being used thus far in alpha version are the ICS209 reports, GeoMAC shapefiles and HMS fire detects
- Technical documentation of beta version to be moved to next month discussion
- Reviewed upcoming schedule and discussed
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
- Investigate possibility of including other federal databases (e.g. USFS FACTS) in future versions of 2016 inventory (Vukovich, Rao)
- Post ICS-209 Acess file
- Next call September 6th, 1PM ET, 11AM MT
July 12, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Provided SF2/Bsky output data to Trent Wickman and rest of workgroup (Vukovich)
- available at this link : https://drive.google.com/open?id=18Tvu4eQKxv-auZujXBYUt9RNbsN4daot
- Update on draft outline for prescribed burning database problem statement (Moore)
- Major Grassland fires in OK and KS update
- Attached to meeting invite or https://drive.google.com/open?id=14xdTa-SXnNLuY3p4OU19zbfjgNxAlcAE
- Discussion on moving all Grassland fires from EPA-Pouliot Ag/Grass method to the SmartFire/BlueSky method
- States submitting specific data for beta version
- Kansas: recommended changes to prescribed and agricultural fires; EPA designing approach to use this
- Georgia: total replacement of all fire type inventories (in progress)
- Others that plan to submit??
- Ag burns for 2014NEI consists of annual-county emissions; do some states want to use this inventory for ag burns?
- Need your data by Friday Aug 17th for implementation into beta version
- Punchlist of improvements for beta version can be found here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1xkVMmlNyqEmMjRtHOMW9_e_WTRAONeQ4Ceif4zmB7CA
- Follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules
- some progress but doubtful in time for beta version; maybe for 2016 version 1
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call and review of last call's minutes/action items
- Tom Moore presented his outline of the prescribed burning database problem statement
- Jeff Vukovich presented results from a SmartFire2 sensitivity that moved a subset of grassland fires from EPA Pouliot ag/grass method pathway to SF2 pathway
- Double-counting was eliminated
- Improved temporal allocation of acres burned for these 2 major wild grassland fires were seen
- Recommendation was to move all grassland fires from EPA Pouliot method pathway to the SF2/BlueSky pathway
- States can make different recommendation for their own state if desired
- Group mentioned it would be good to track these grassland detects and possible assign a different SCC to these fires
- States are progressing with inventory changes for the beta version
- GA, KS are submitting changes
- WA and ID will be submitting changes; Nez Perce tribe changes likely coming too
- USFS (Trent Wickman) will be providing QA feedback soon
- Need your data by Friday Aug 17th for implementation into beta version
- Punchlist of improvements for beta version can be found here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1xkVMmlNyqEmMjRtHOMW9_e_WTRAONeQ4Ceif4zmB7CA
- Continued efforts are being made to follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules
- some progress but doubtful in time for beta version; maybe for 2016 version 1
- Next workgroup conference call scheduled for Thursday Aug 2, 2018 at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Action Items
- Please review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Additional feedback with regard to moving all grassland fires to the SmartFire2/Bluesky pathway (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
June 7, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Corrected acres burned report by event name at: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1sm02OgbO9ibofrcvmvKlimIdkf-6FMgb
- Next call: July 5th or 12th or ?
- State/MJO QA
- Revisit CARB QA: Focus on slides 11 and 12 (Klaus Scott)
- WRAP QA (M. Mavko and T. Moore)
- Process for states, others to submit 2016 inventory data/changes
- Submittal form can be found on Google Drive here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1OXpQN406cK-x59f44BCT7y4s4B_Sel4H
- or xls attached to WG meeting invite
- Started punchlist/wishlist document for improvements to beta version (Vukovich)
Minutes/Notes
- Next call will be July 12 at 1PM ET (it would usually be 7/5 but moved due to holiday)
- CARB and WRAP QA presentations shown and discussed
- Further QA of Soberanes acres burned needed
- Named event totals can be impacted by SmartFire2 settings; don't get too caught up in differences but good to QA this for major fires
- Generic form for submitting data for 2016 inventory updates (2016 beta and 2016v1) was shown and briefly discussed
- Workgroup members encouraged to edit/add to punchlist document for 2016 beta
- More discussion regarding getting USFS AIRFIRE team more involved and knowing more about the possible release of new BlueSky modules
- Farren indicated that he would contact Susan O'Neil about this
- Trent Wickman requested the SF2/BSky output data so he could do some QA
- Other possible federal databases used in NEI year inventories were discussed
- Performing retro analysis for a historic year with new modules is very much needed; is AIRFIRE doing this or only in forecasts mode?
- Problem statement idea for prescribed burning database suggested by Tom Moore
- Problem centers around getting a good consistent prescribed burning database organized
- Challenges include cloud cover impacting satellite detection methods, pile burns, permiting, not knowing exact day prescribe fire actually occurred (or if it occurred at all?), etc.
- Tom Moore with draft an outline of problem statement
Action Items
- Further QA the Soberanes fire in CA for acres burned vs. observed/CARB totals (Vukovich)
- States/local/tribes/MJOs have form to submit specific changes/data for their region for implementation in beta (and/or v1) of 2016 inventory (ALL)
- All workgroup members encouraged to add/edit punchlist/wishlist document for 2016 inventory changes for beta version (ALL)
- Follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules (Herron-Thorpe, Vukovich, Rao)
- Provide SF2/Bsky output data to Trent Wickman and rest of workgroup (Vukovich)
- Draft an outline for prescribed burning database problem statement (Moore)
May 9, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- GA NEI 2014 fire inventory description: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1nxMP-5MXo_mxcHC1oJqfLTPQPcVwwO_N
- Ag burn/grassland QA reports generated for WG (Vukovich)
- Folder with QA reports - https://drive.google.com/open?id=1M93mfo2wgoHlJUse1iKZHVI5XlklHMar
- Inquire about need for HAPs in beta version (Co-leads): ANSWER = YES
- Finalized Workgroup charge document by Friday April 13(ALL)
- Temporal and chemical speciation review (Vukovich and Rao)
- More state QA of 2016 alpha version
- CARB (Klaus Scott)
- Next call: Thursday June 7th at 1PM ET
Minutes/Notes
- States should review ag/grassland fire reports if possible
- Must include HAPS emissions for beta and version 1
- Workgroup charge document finalized
- Temporal and speciation profiles currently being used in modeling platform for fires were reviewed
- Speciation profiles presentation given by Tesh Rao (EPA): see Agenda ppt
- Klaus Scott provided QA ppt for CA fires
- Acres burned off by a factor of two or more in most cases
- Investigation needed into this
Action Items
- If possible, states should review ag/grassland fire reports provided (ALL)
- If states have feedback on temporal and speciation profiles, please provide this ASAP (ALL)
- Post form to submit changes to fire inventory for beta version (Vukovich,Rao)
- Examine why differences in acres burned based on CARB presentation (Vukovich)
- Make current punchlist/wish-list for beta version document available to group (Vukovich)
April 5, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Ag/grassland fire and prescribed fire classification process (Vukovich)
- State review/feedback/plans thus far (brief summary)
- Washington (Farren Herron-Thorpe)
- Georgia (Tao Zeng)
- North Carolina (Randy Strait)
- QA reports now available
- Daily-county and Event reports
- Discussion on how to define scope and desired improvements for beta version of 2016 fire inventory (All)
- Develop a punch-list doc on Google Drive?
- Closure on charge document (Moore and Vukovich)
- Next call: Thursday May 3rd at 1PM ET
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call completed
- Briefly went over Action Items from minutes from March call
- Vukovich went over Fire Classification overview for Ag, Grassland and Rx fires (see presentation in Agenda)
- CARB mentioned that finding the ICS-209 reports on the FAMWEB site can be challenging
- Presentation has link to ICS-209 reports for others to download
- Concerns about lack of Federal land fire info were mentioned
- State feedback discussion
- Washington state
- Has reviewed Grassland/Pasture fires and have concern with CDL database in some cases
- Will be moving some Rx fires to Ag burn category for 2016
- Suggested the use of a national and state park lands shapefile for further QA of ag/grassland detects and perhaps it has other uses
- In 2014 analysis, Ag burns were underestimated in NEI2014 by factor of 3; did submit some burn data to nonpoint sector for NEI2014
- Idaho mentioned that they will likely be submitting ag burn data for 2016
- data will be day-specific with latitude-longitude information
- Vukovich mentioned some of the possible drawbacks of submitting county data on annual temporal resolution
- If states can submit data on monthly temporal resolution that would be good too, but day-specific and lat-lon info the best case
- Georgia
- Will be submitting their own fire inventory for year 2016
- Includes wildfire and prescribed fire emissions (smoldering and flaming separated), acres burned and heat flux info and ag detect info
- Will compare their 2016 inventory vs. 2016 alpha
- Georgia willing to share NEI2014 document on their inventory generation process; will post to Google Drive
- Asked whether HAPs emissions needed
- Tom Moore mentioned that overall 2016 Collaborative WG leaders have indicated that HAPs is desired for beta version
- North Carolina
- Rx acres burned much higher in 2016 alpha inventory vs. NC fire databases; see presentation
- Showed Fort Bragg case study and plan to submit better activity data for year 2016
- USFS (Wickman) mentioned that Federal lands fire database helps with improving fire inventories
- Workgroup will include working on getting access to these database(s) as part of discussions with AIRFIRE team
- NCDAQ mentioned they tried to access this Federal database unsuccessfully
- Daily and Event-based emissions reports now available; see agenda for links or goto QA folder on Google Drive
- If more QA reports needed, please let co-leads know
- Punchlist or wish list of desired updates for beta version discussed
- a Google doc will be started with all in the group encourage to add to the list now and in the future
- Temporal and Speciation profile presentation moved to next month
- Charge document closure needed
- Send all comments on the charge document to co-leads by Friday April 13
- Next call is May 3rd 1PM ET
Action Items
- Ag burn QA reports generated for WG (Vukovich)
- Continued to communicate with AIRFIRE team about assistance regarding BSky modules and input data (Co-leads and Rao)
- State continue to review alpha inventory and report findings (ALL)
- Start punchlist/wishlist document for improvements to beta version (Vukovich)
- Finalized Workgroup charge document by Friday April 13(ALL)
- Post GA's NEI2014 fire inventory documentation (GA, EPA)
- Inquire about need for HAPs in beta version (Co-leads)
- Investigate use of a national/state park lands shapefile for QA of alpha inventory (EPA, WA)
March 1, 2018
AttendeesCo-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
- See following link for list of attendees:
Agenda
- Introductions, roll call – name, daily job responsibilities with respect to fire and smoke issues, agency
- set up regular meeting times for workgroup
- suggest first Thursday of month at 1PM ET (like today)
- build agenda for monthly calls based on a 60-min. duration
- Collaboration mission: Develop a year 2016 Emissions Modeling Platform
- Review draft Charge Document for the Workgroup
- Fires Workgroup Charge Document (draft dated March 1, 2018)
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits, finalize on next call
- Using the 2016 EMP Wiki and Google document folders
- Fire Workgroup wiki page
- Google Drive Fire Workgroup Folder
- Draft 2016 fire inventory summary (alpha version)
- ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/alpha/2016fd/emissions/
- Overview data, suggestions for quality control / assurance
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits
- Draft 2016 fire inventory technical memo (alpha version)
- Fires Tech Memo Document (draft dated Feb 22, 2018)
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call taken and members given opportunity to briefly explain their daily job activities as it relates to fire inventories/modeling
- Group will have a call once a month on first Thursday at 1PM ET
- Overall Collaboration mission was described and wiki pages introduced for more information
- Reviewed Draft Fires Workgroup charge document
- Introduced the Fire Workgroup wiki webpage and Google Drive folder
- Briefly covered the Wildland fires tech memo for the Alpha version of the 2016 fire inventory
- Question by Farren Herron-Thorpe: Will this workgroup work on international fire inventories as well? (Canada and Mexico)
- Klaus Scott mentioned that CARB may have plans to QA the ag burns and prescribed fires in CA
- Trent Wickman: would like to compare 2011 and 2014 prescribed fires vs. the alpha version 2016 fires especially for Midwest region
- Group should consider including pile burns in future versions if possible
- Other QA products already available were introduced/shared
- Concern on how much time workgroup members have to QA fires
- List of information about top fires in nation for 2016 needed
- Brief discussion on emissions modeling platform issues (speciation, hourly profile, plume-rise)
Action Items
- All possible workgroup members review Draft Fire Workgroup Charge document (dated March 1, 2018)
- All possible workgroup members review Wildland fires technical memo for Alpha version of 2016 fire inventory (dated Feb 22, 2018)
- All possible workgroup members review the QA products/maps for the alpha version of the fire inventory (in QA folder on Google Drive)
- All possible workgroup members review the alpha version fire inventory in SMOKE format
- All workgroup members provided a list of desired QA products for fire inventories/model platform development
- Develop list of information (emissions, acres-burned) of top fires in nation in 2016 from alpha version of inventory (USEPA, Vukovich)
- Contact and invite AIRFIRE team to provide more information on how to obtain Bluesky module updates during future workgroup call (USEPA, Rao and Vukovich)
- Develop technical memo describing the current approach for handling fire emissions modeling temporal, speciation and vertical allocation issues at EPA (USEPA, Vukovich)
- Agenda items for future calls
- Closure on Charge doc
- Milestones for Fire Workgroup
- “stable” modules and complete activity data for using BlueSky framework to prepare historic and future projection fire EIs
- Discussion on how to define scope and desired improvements for beta version of 2016 fire inventory
- Key parameterizations of fire activity data (consumption, fuel loadings, acres and piles, plume rise, speciation profiles, others)
- Estimating future fire emissions to bound air quality planning projections