Fire Workgroup
Inventory Collaborative Google Drive Link
Members
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader- See following link for list of members:
Coordination Committee Meetings
June 6, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Agenda
- Roll call
- Action Items from last call
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in July possible (Moore, Mavko)
- 2016 Inventory to be presented at EPA Emissions Inventory Conference Jul 29-Aug 2
- Schedule
- Post preliminary 2016v1 emissions next week!
Alaska acres burned and emissions for v1 delayed a week or two- Short call on June 25 2PM ET: Last minute feedback for 2016v1
- July 18 Workgroup call 1PM ET: Summarizing 2016v1
- PM2.5 speciation update
- Last workgroup call to be August call
- Status of 2016v1 fires (USEPA)
- Next call Tues Jun 25 2PM ET
May 2, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader
Agenda
- Roll call
- Action Items from last call
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in upcoming meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- EPA and NCDENR met; may have something to present during June call
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Discuss if this is still doable for June?
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
- Possibly in 2020 TBD
- CARB and EPA to discuss recent modeling findings Re: Soberanes fire (CARB and EPA)
- Met this week
- Soberanes Fire, CA (pdf)
- CARB has provided event data from FOFEM database (5/1/2019)
- Next steps to get any improvements TBD
- Provide workgroup with findings of top fire cases where acres_bruned-PM2.5-SO2 emissions high for a daily location (Vukovich)
- Spreadsheet part of meeting invite (also available here Top daily emissions cases in 2016beta (xls) )
- Status of 2016v1 fire processing update (Vukovich)
- New USFS, USFWS, and NJ data formatted and ready for use
- Changes to NASF database complete
- Next call is Thursday June 6th at 1PM ET
- Expecting preliminary 2016v1 results before and during June call
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- EPA met with NCDENR and will continue to discuss possible topics to present to Workgroup
- EPA to follow up with Tom Moore about future-year alternative scenarios for fires to see if there will be a presentation for June call
- EPA met with CARB about Soberanes fire and July 26th high emissions issue
- CARB provided event information for Soberanes fires; EPA will examine
- T. Wickman suggested looking at duff consumption
- G. Pouliot suggested changing temporal profile for July 26th
- Ferron suggested looking at canopy consumption percentage for fuel *(default may be set to 60%)
- EPA went over top daily PM2.5 emitting cases with Workgroup
- One result is some bogus fire information will be removed from National Association of State Foresters (NASF) data that is input into SmartFire2
- Preliminary SmartFire2 run for 2016v1 is about to start at EPA
- Results will be shared with Workgroup
Action Items
- Provide data summaries of preliminary version 1 Smartfire2/Bluesky simulation to workgroup (EPA)
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in June's meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
April 4, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Need another co-leader
Agenda
- Roll call
- EPA Emissions Inventory Conference in Dallas on July 29 - August 2, 2019
- Action Items from last call
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (ALL)
- http://views.cira.colostate.edu/wiki/wiki/10197#Documentation
- Workgroup members encouraged to provide feedback
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Received; hope to implement in 2016v1
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios (Mavko, Moore)
- Future Fire Scenarios for Regional Haze Planning (pdf)
- Discussion
- Update on 2016v1 plan (Vukovich)
- Workgroup Plans (pdf)
- Next call is on Thursday May 2nd at 1pm ET, 11am MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- Workgroup members encouraged to read fire documentation and provide feedback
- NJ fire information to be used in v1
- Matt Mavko presented issues involved when coming up with future year fire scenarios
- Discussion afterwards included topics
- What area will be covered? USA only
- Boundary conditions for year 2028
- How many scenarios? 2 to be used may examine more
- WRAP driving this work but could use input from Plains and SE USA
- Matt can provide more details of this work during June's workgroup call
- SE US : Randy Strait gave a quick update on Regional Haze modeling in SE and prescribed fire impacts
- Vukovich gave a quick update on 2016v1 plans in the coming months
- Mentioned an air quality modeling effort that found a possible issue with Soberanes fire in CA on July 26, 2016
- Tom Moore suggested looking at other possible similar cases
- EPA has started this process already
- Tom Moore suggested a webinar or meeting of land managers and states to discuss 2016 modeling platform issues related to fire information issues encountered.
Action Items
- Provide workgroup with findings of top 25 fire cases where acres_bruned-PM2.5-SO2 emissions high for a daily location (Vukovich)
- CARB and EPA to discuss recent modeling findings Re: Soberanes fire (CARB and EPA)
- NCDENR and EPA to discuss recent Regional Haze modeling with VISTAS project and see what information may be worth showing workgroup in May's meeting (EPA and NCDENR)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios follow-up in June (Moore, Mavko)
- Consider a future webinar for states, land managers and others on using fire information in fire modeling tools and other related topics (Vukovich)
March 7, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- EPA Emissions Inventory Conference in Dallas on July 29 - August 2, 2019
- Training thoughts survey (optional): https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/9NR3FGG
- Biomass burning/Fires session very likely; need co-chair person for session
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Provided 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Update on timing for New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Pre-version 1 Smartfire-Bluesky run planned for late March-early April
- Need time to review all of the impacts of the new input data
- Workgroup Plans (pdf)
- Summary of other N. American fires used in regional modeling domains (Canada/Mexico) for 2016 (Vukovich)
- ptfire_othna sector (pdf)
- Next call is April 4, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
- Agenda for this call will include alternative future-year fire scenarios ppt and discussion
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- Fire/Biomass Burning session at EPA's EIC needs a co-chair
- Fill out optional survey on EPA EIC desired training
- New Jersey fire activity for 2016 coming real soon
- Pre-v1 Smartfire-Bluesky planned to start late March or early April
- A summary of 2016 fire season for Canada and Mexico was presented
- GA DNR suggested examining other global inventories (e.g. GFED)
Action Items
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
February 7, 2019
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- January's call was cancelled due to government shutdown
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- 2016 beta fires inventory and report/summaries located on Google Drive
- https://drive.google.com/drive/u/1/folders/15HbKPUiV-YOLhXYCu3nNyjyB4rjTEnG5
- Includes ancillary data (profiles, xrefs) needed for emissions modeling
- More 2016 beta fires reports
- Update on beta documentation
- Moving towards 2016 version 1 (pdf)
- Does any federal/states/local/tribal agency plan on submitting new fire activity data for 2016 version 1?
- Does any federal/states/local/tribal agency plan on quality assuring the beta inventory and providing feedback?
- Next call March 7, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Reviewed last call's action items
- 2016 beta inventory data and summaries/reports now available
- 2016 beta documentation will be made available to the workgroup around Feb 15th timeframe
- FACTS fire information database contains prescribed burns only according to USFS
- FACTS will be in used in 2016v1 development
- Randy Strait mentioned that some latitude-longitude coordinates only have two decimal places and may not be accurate enough for use
- NFPORS fire information will also be used in 2016v1 development and it also contains USFWS fire information
- New Jersey has indicated it will submit some 2016 fire activity data for use in 2016v1
Action Items
- Provide 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Provide New Jersey fire information for use 2016v1 (NJ)
- Provide a summary of international fires used in regional modeling domains (Canada/Mexico) for 2016 (Vukovich)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
December 6, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Follow-up on NCDENR on plan for 2016v1 (EPA)
- Final 2016 beta emissions inventory (Vukovich)
- Last minute change to 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- Inventory files located at: https://drive.google.com/open?id=15HbKPUiV-YOLhXYCu3nNyjyB4rjTEnG5
- Provide beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
- Next call January 10, 2019 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- T. Moore may be able to update at next call on Rx fire problem statement doc
- J Vukovich went over the 2016beta last minute change involved the national fire info dataset called MTBS.
- Please see pdf listed in agenda
- Future work with more national fire info datasets mentioned
- P Corrigan (UT/Forest Service) mentioned he has input on these national datasets
- 2016 beta fire inventories released and available (see link in Agenda)
- 2016beta documentation: hope to make progress before next call
- No future-year fire scenarios discussed
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- P. Corrigan to provide input on national fire info datasets
- Future-year alternative fire scenarios discussion? (Moore, others?)
November 1, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Communicated with AIRFIRE team that we have 2016 beta data they can test with latest BlueSky software
- Follow-up with M. Mavko on what could be done to use NFEI tool with 2016 data (Vukovich, Moore, Mavko)
- Provided data to Matt that may allow him to use NFEI tool for 2016
- Follow-up on NCDENR submitted vs. draft 2016 beta acres burned differences (EPA)
- Provided reports to NCDENR at: ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/beta/reports/fires/NCDENR/
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Actual inventory files to be made available very soon!
- Final summary of 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Next Call December 6th at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- USFS AIRFIRE communication continuing
- Matt Mavko has the necessary 2016 beta data to try to use the NFEI tool
- EPA will followup with NCDENR after call about path for 2016v1
- Summary of 2016 beta inventory discussed and reports provided
- Urban fuel category discussion
- Possible improvements for 2016v1 discussion
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Follow-up on NCDENR on plan for 2016v1 (EPA)
- Finalize 2016 beta emissions inventory (ALL)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
October 4, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup
- Summary of 2016beta inventory (pdf)
- State reports (2016 alpha vs 2016 beta version)
- ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/beta/reports/fires/2016alpha_beta_postBSF_comparison.xlsx : Wildfire and prescribed fires state comparison (updated Oct 31, 2018 !!) (xls)
- Agricultural burns state comparison (xls)
- Draft outline for technical documentation (pdf)
- Documentation can be delivered after the beta inventory is released
- Introduction to a Fire Evaluation tool (Mavko)
- http://nfei2014.airsci.com/2014_fire_nei_eval
- being used for 2014 but possible use for 2016
- Next Meeting November 1 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call
- Review of previous action items
- Summary of draft 2016 beta inventory discussed and initial reports provided
- Trent Wickman requested a report in a format he provided previously for 2016 alpha
- Randy Strait mentioned that state-submitted data for beta version didn't match up as far as acres burned
- Draft outline of 2016 beta documentation discussed
- Matt Mavko shared the Fire Evaluation tool (NFEI tool)
- http://nfei2014.airsci.com/2014_fire_nei_eval
- discussed needs for use with 2016 inventory
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide more beta emissions reports to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Follow-up on NCDENR submitted vs. draft 2016 beta acres burned differences (EPA)
- Finalize 2016 beta emissions inventory (ALL)
- Continue to work on 2016 beta documentation (Co-leaders, others)
- Follow-up with M. Mavko on what could be done to use NFEI tool with 2016 data (Vukovich, Moore, Mavko)
September 6, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Plan for 2016 beta version fires(pdf)(dated Sep 6, 2018)
- Summarize data received from states, tribes and other government agencies
- Other fire information to be used
- Fuel-bed information updated
- Technical documentation for beta version discussion (Tom Moore)
- Beta Schedule
- Week of Sept 24th: Draft beta version available for QA
- Oct 04: Another workgroup call; early draft beta QA findings; tech doc progress update
- October: More QA and work on tech doc for beta version
- Nov 01: Another workgroup call and release beta version and tech doc
- Next Meeting Oct 4 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Minutes/Notes
- Prescribed Burn Problem statement discussion
- More states want to contribute
- Discussion on need for Ag burning documentation
- Pouliot has published paper
- Will include for beta documentation
- Summary of changes to inventory input for 2016 beta presented
- More information on NASF and Landfire v1.4 desired
- HAPS discussion: why is this needed?
- Ag burn plan for 2017NEI discussion
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- https://drive.google.com/open?id=1O8anOqaSEuyfcbSyX3NZLjRTmRqOg2dM
- Also sent MS Word version to Workgroup (Vukovich)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software and fire information databases (EPA, others)
- Provide draft beta emissions to workgroup (Vukovich)
- Prepare outline for technical documentation (Moore)
August 2, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Please review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
- NEI: emissions factor and speciation update (EPA-ORD, Amara Holder)
- US Forest Service QA (Trent Wickman)
- Technical documentation for beta version discussion (Tom Moore)
- List of potenial improvements for beta version (pdf)(dated Aug 2, 2018)
- Upcoming schedule
- Aug 17: Inventory/activity changes due
- Sep 06: Next workgroup conference call scheduled for Thursday September 6, 2018 at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
- Sep 21: Draft beta version available for QA
- Oct 04: Another workgroup call; early draft beta QA findings; tech doc progress update
- October: More QA and finalize tech doc for beta version
- Nov 01: Another workgroup call and release beta version
Minutes/Notes
- Activity/emissions updates for beta version due Aug 17th
- EPA meeting with USFS AIRFIRE via conference call very soon
- Amara Holder presented updates on PM emissions factors and speciation from EPA-ORD research efforts
- PM2.5 emissions would increase based on these initial lab results
- MN peat moss/other fuels lab burns delayed; may begin in September
- Black Carbon impacts discussed by group
- Trent Wickman, USFS, presented his QA of MN fires
- See spreadsheet
- 7 prescribed fires should be ag fires
- Acreage differences hint at other federal databases missing
- EPA: only databases being used thus far in alpha version are the ICS209 reports, GeoMAC shapefiles and HMS fire detects
- Technical documentation of beta version to be moved to next month discussion
- Reviewed upcoming schedule and discussed
Action Items
- Please continue to review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
- Investigate possibility of including other federal databases (e.g. USFS FACTS) in future versions of 2016 inventory (Vukovich, Rao)
- Post ICS-209 Acess file
- Next call September 6th, 1PM ET, 11AM MT
July 12, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Provided SF2/Bsky output data to Trent Wickman and rest of workgroup (Vukovich)
- available at this link : https://drive.google.com/open?id=18Tvu4eQKxv-auZujXBYUt9RNbsN4daot
- Update on draft outline for prescribed burning database problem statement (Moore)
- Major Grassland fires in OK and KS update
- Attached to meeting invite or https://drive.google.com/open?id=14xdTa-SXnNLuY3p4OU19zbfjgNxAlcAE
- Discussion on moving all Grassland fires from EPA-Pouliot Ag/Grass method to the SmartFire/BlueSky method
- States submitting specific data for beta version
- Kansas: recommended changes to prescribed and agricultural fires; EPA designing approach to use this
- Georgia: total replacement of all fire type inventories (in progress)
- Others that plan to submit??
- Ag burns for 2014NEI consists of annual-county emissions; do some states want to use this inventory for ag burns?
- Need your data by Friday Aug 17th for implementation into beta version
- Punchlist of improvements for beta version can be found here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1xkVMmlNyqEmMjRtHOMW9_e_WTRAONeQ4Ceif4zmB7CA
- Follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules
- some progress but doubtful in time for beta version; maybe for 2016 version 1
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call and review of last call's minutes/action items
- Tom Moore presented his outline of the prescribed burning database problem statement
- Jeff Vukovich presented results from a SmartFire2 sensitivity that moved a subset of grassland fires from EPA Pouliot ag/grass method pathway to SF2 pathway
- Double-counting was eliminated
- Improved temporal allocation of acres burned for these 2 major wild grassland fires were seen
- Recommendation was to move all grassland fires from EPA Pouliot method pathway to the SF2/BlueSky pathway
- States can make different recommendation for their own state if desired
- Group mentioned it would be good to track these grassland detects and possible assign a different SCC to these fires
- States are progressing with inventory changes for the beta version
- GA, KS are submitting changes
- WA and ID will be submitting changes; Nez Perce tribe changes likely coming too
- USFS (Trent Wickman) will be providing QA feedback soon
- Need your data by Friday Aug 17th for implementation into beta version
- Punchlist of improvements for beta version can be found here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1xkVMmlNyqEmMjRtHOMW9_e_WTRAONeQ4Ceif4zmB7CA
- Continued efforts are being made to follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules
- some progress but doubtful in time for beta version; maybe for 2016 version 1
- Next workgroup conference call scheduled for Thursday Aug 2, 2018 at 1PM ET, 11AM MT
Action Items
- Please review Tom Moore's outline of the prescribed burn problem statement (ALL)
- States/tribes/others need to submit inventory/activity changes for beta version by Aug 17th (ALL)
- Additional feedback with regard to moving all grassland fires to the SmartFire2/Bluesky pathway (ALL)
- Continue efforts to meet with USFS AIRFIRE team about updates to software (EPA, others)
June 7, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Corrected acres burned report by event name at: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1sm02OgbO9ibofrcvmvKlimIdkf-6FMgb
- Next call: July 5th or 12th or ?
- State/MJO QA
- Revisit CARB QA: Focus on slides 11 and 12 (Klaus Scott)
- WRAP QA (M. Mavko and T. Moore)
- Process for states, others to submit 2016 inventory data/changes
- Submittal form can be found on Google Drive here: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1OXpQN406cK-x59f44BCT7y4s4B_Sel4H
- or xls attached to WG meeting invite
- Started punchlist/wishlist document for improvements to beta version (Vukovich)
Minutes/Notes
- Next call will be July 12 at 1PM ET (it would usually be 7/5 but moved due to holiday)
- CARB and WRAP QA presentations shown and discussed
- Further QA of Soberanes acres burned needed
- Named event totals can be impacted by SmartFire2 settings; don't get too caught up in differences but good to QA this for major fires
- Generic form for submitting data for 2016 inventory updates (2016 beta and 2016v1) was shown and briefly discussed
- Workgroup members encouraged to edit/add to punchlist document for 2016 beta
- More discussion regarding getting USFS AIRFIRE team more involved and knowing more about the possible release of new BlueSky modules
- Farren indicated that he would contact Susan O'Neil about this
- Trent Wickman requested the SF2/BSky output data so he could do some QA
- Other possible federal databases used in NEI year inventories were discussed
- Performing retro analysis for a historic year with new modules is very much needed; is AIRFIRE doing this or only in forecasts mode?
- Problem statement idea for prescribed burning database suggested by Tom Moore
- Problem centers around getting a good consistent prescribed burning database organized
- Challenges include cloud cover impacting satellite detection methods, pile burns, permiting, not knowing exact day prescribe fire actually occurred (or if it occurred at all?), etc.
- Tom Moore with draft an outline of problem statement
Action Items
- Further QA the Soberanes fire in CA for acres burned vs. observed/CARB totals (Vukovich)
- States/local/tribes/MJOs have form to submit specific changes/data for their region for implementation in beta (and/or v1) of 2016 inventory (ALL)
- All workgroup members encouraged to add/edit punchlist/wishlist document for 2016 inventory changes for beta version (ALL)
- Follow-up with USFS and AIRFIRE team to get more information on the accessibility of the new Blue Sky modules (Herron-Thorpe, Vukovich, Rao)
- Provide SF2/Bsky output data to Trent Wickman and rest of workgroup (Vukovich)
- Draft an outline for prescribed burning database problem statement (Moore)
May 9, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- GA NEI 2014 fire inventory description: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1nxMP-5MXo_mxcHC1oJqfLTPQPcVwwO_N
- Ag burn/grassland QA reports generated for WG (Vukovich)
- Folder with QA reports - https://drive.google.com/open?id=1M93mfo2wgoHlJUse1iKZHVI5XlklHMar
- Inquire about need for HAPs in beta version (Co-leads): ANSWER = YES
- Finalized Workgroup charge document by Friday April 13(ALL)
- Temporal and chemical speciation review (Vukovich and Rao)
- More state QA of 2016 alpha version
- CARB (Klaus Scott)
- Next call: Thursday June 7th at 1PM ET
Minutes/Notes
- States should review ag/grassland fire reports if possible
- Must include HAPS emissions for beta and version 1
- Workgroup charge document finalized
- Temporal and speciation profiles currently being used in modeling platform for fires were reviewed
- Speciation profiles presentation given by Tesh Rao (EPA): see Agenda ppt
- Klaus Scott provided QA ppt for CA fires
- Acres burned off by a factor of two or more in most cases
- Investigation needed into this
Action Items
- If possible, states should review ag/grassland fire reports provided (ALL)
- If states have feedback on temporal and speciation profiles, please provide this ASAP (ALL)
- Post form to submit changes to fire inventory for beta version (Vukovich,Rao)
- Examine why differences in acres burned based on CARB presentation (Vukovich)
- Make current punchlist/wish-list for beta version document available to group (Vukovich)
April 5, 2018
Attendees- See following link for list of attendees:
Co-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
Agenda
- Roll call
- Briefly review Action Items from last call
- Ag/grassland fire and prescribed fire classification process (Vukovich)
- State review/feedback/plans thus far (brief summary)
- Washington (Farren Herron-Thorpe)
- Georgia (Tao Zeng)
- North Carolina (Randy Strait)
- QA reports now available
- Daily-county and Event reports
- Discussion on how to define scope and desired improvements for beta version of 2016 fire inventory (All)
- Develop a punch-list doc on Google Drive?
- Closure on charge document (Moore and Vukovich)
- Next call: Thursday May 3rd at 1PM ET
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call completed
- Briefly went over Action Items from minutes from March call
- Vukovich went over Fire Classification overview for Ag, Grassland and Rx fires (see presentation in Agenda)
- CARB mentioned that finding the ICS-209 reports on the FAMWEB site can be challenging
- Presentation has link to ICS-209 reports for others to download
- Concerns about lack of Federal land fire info were mentioned
- State feedback discussion
- Washington state
- Has reviewed Grassland/Pasture fires and have concern with CDL database in some cases
- Will be moving some Rx fires to Ag burn category for 2016
- Suggested the use of a national and state park lands shapefile for further QA of ag/grassland detects and perhaps it has other uses
- In 2014 analysis, Ag burns were underestimated in NEI2014 by factor of 3; did submit some burn data to nonpoint sector for NEI2014
- Idaho mentioned that they will likely be submitting ag burn data for 2016
- data will be day-specific with latitude-longitude information
- Vukovich mentioned some of the possible drawbacks of submitting county data on annual temporal resolution
- If states can submit data on monthly temporal resolution that would be good too, but day-specific and lat-lon info the best case
- Georgia
- Will be submitting their own fire inventory for year 2016
- Includes wildfire and prescribed fire emissions (smoldering and flaming separated), acres burned and heat flux info and ag detect info
- Will compare their 2016 inventory vs. 2016 alpha
- Georgia willing to share NEI2014 document on their inventory generation process; will post to Google Drive
- Asked whether HAPs emissions needed
- Tom Moore mentioned that overall 2016 Collaborative WG leaders have indicated that HAPs is desired for beta version
- North Carolina
- Rx acres burned much higher in 2016 alpha inventory vs. NC fire databases; see presentation
- Showed Fort Bragg case study and plan to submit better activity data for year 2016
- USFS (Wickman) mentioned that Federal lands fire database helps with improving fire inventories
- Workgroup will include working on getting access to these database(s) as part of discussions with AIRFIRE team
- NCDAQ mentioned they tried to access this Federal database unsuccessfully
- Daily and Event-based emissions reports now available; see agenda for links or goto QA folder on Google Drive
- If more QA reports needed, please let co-leads know
- Punchlist or wish list of desired updates for beta version discussed
- a Google doc will be started with all in the group encourage to add to the list now and in the future
- Temporal and Speciation profile presentation moved to next month
- Charge document closure needed
- Send all comments on the charge document to co-leads by Friday April 13
- Next call is May 3rd 1PM ET
Action Items
- Ag burn QA reports generated for WG (Vukovich)
- Continued to communicate with AIRFIRE team about assistance regarding BSky modules and input data (Co-leads and Rao)
- State continue to review alpha inventory and report findings (ALL)
- Start punchlist/wishlist document for improvements to beta version (Vukovich)
- Finalized Workgroup charge document by Friday April 13(ALL)
- Post GA's NEI2014 fire inventory documentation (GA, EPA)
- Inquire about need for HAPs in beta version (Co-leads)
- Investigate use of a national/state park lands shapefile for QA of alpha inventory (EPA, WA)
March 1, 2018
AttendeesCo-leads: Jeff Vukovich (USEPA), Tom Moore (WRAP)
- See following link for list of attendees:
Agenda
- Introductions, roll call – name, daily job responsibilities with respect to fire and smoke issues, agency
- set up regular meeting times for workgroup
- suggest first Thursday of month at 1PM ET (like today)
- build agenda for monthly calls based on a 60-min. duration
- Collaboration mission: Develop a year 2016 Emissions Modeling Platform
- Review draft Charge Document for the Workgroup
- Fires Workgroup Charge Document (draft dated March 1, 2018)
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits, finalize on next call
- Using the 2016 EMP Wiki and Google document folders
- Fire Workgroup wiki page
- Google Drive Fire Workgroup Folder
- Draft 2016 fire inventory summary (alpha version)
- ftp://newftp.epa.gov/Air/emismod/2016/alpha/2016fd/emissions/
- Overview data, suggestions for quality control / assurance
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits
- Draft 2016 fire inventory technical memo (alpha version)
- Fires Tech Memo Document (draft dated Feb 22, 2018)
- Discuss timeframe for review and edits
Minutes/Notes
- Roll call taken and members given opportunity to briefly explain their daily job activities as it relates to fire inventories/modeling
- Group will have a call once a month on first Thursday at 1PM ET
- Overall Collaboration mission was described and wiki pages introduced for more information
- Reviewed Draft Fires Workgroup charge document
- Introduced the Fire Workgroup wiki webpage and Google Drive folder
- Briefly covered the Wildland fires tech memo for the Alpha version of the 2016 fire inventory
- Question by Farren Herron-Thorpe: Will this workgroup work on international fire inventories as well? (Canada and Mexico)
- Klaus Scott mentioned that CARB may have plans to QA the ag burns and prescribed fires in CA
- Trent Wickman: would like to compare 2011 and 2014 prescribed fires vs. the alpha version 2016 fires especially for Midwest region
- Group should consider including pile burns in future versions if possible
- Other QA products already available were introduced/shared
- Concern on how much time workgroup members have to QA fires
- List of information about top fires in nation for 2016 needed
- Brief discussion on emissions modeling platform issues (speciation, hourly profile, plume-rise)
Action Items
- All possible workgroup members review Draft Fire Workgroup Charge document (dated March 1, 2018)
- All possible workgroup members review Wildland fires technical memo for Alpha version of 2016 fire inventory (dated Feb 22, 2018)
- All possible workgroup members review the QA products/maps for the alpha version of the fire inventory (in QA folder on Google Drive)
- All possible workgroup members review the alpha version fire inventory in SMOKE format
- All workgroup members provided a list of desired QA products for fire inventories/model platform development
- Develop list of information (emissions, acres-burned) of top fires in nation in 2016 from alpha version of inventory (USEPA, Vukovich)
- Contact and invite AIRFIRE team to provide more information on how to obtain Bluesky module updates during future workgroup call (USEPA, Rao and Vukovich)
- Develop technical memo describing the current approach for handling fire emissions modeling temporal, speciation and vertical allocation issues at EPA (USEPA, Vukovich)
- Agenda items for future calls
- Closure on Charge doc
- Milestones for Fire Workgroup
- “stable” modules and complete activity data for using BlueSky framework to prepare historic and future projection fire EIs
- Discussion on how to define scope and desired improvements for beta version of 2016 fire inventory
- Key parameterizations of fire activity data (consumption, fuel loadings, acres and piles, plume rise, speciation profiles, others)
- Estimating future fire emissions to bound air quality planning projections